
There is Herreninsel, the Island of Men.
And there is Fraueninsel, the Island of Women.
Two small islands in Chiemsee, Lake Chiemsee.
A large lake – the circumference is over 60 kilometers – in Bavaria in southern Germany, between Rosenheim and Salzburg.
A well-known and beloved holiday paradise.
And at the same time a lake with a completely different kind of Paradise: On the two small islands are two monasteries.
One of the monasteries is extinct, closed down. On the island of the lords, the monks are gone and the buildings have become a museum.
But nuns still live on the island of women to this day.
That's where we're headed.
I am traveling with my friend and fellow teacher, anthropologist Martijn van Beek.
We arrive by ferry.
First stop is Herreninsel. Above the ferry dock rises a mighty, whitewashed building: the old monastery.
In a way abandoned – and in a way kept alive by the museum's historical interest.
We sail on.
Towards Fraueninsel.
Where Martijn and I will be carrying out a teaching assignment for the organization Mind&Life.
We pass small uninhabited islands with grazing sheep. Chiemsee is quiet, breathtakingly beautiful, surrounded by the silhouette of the Alps.
A new island comes into view. The captain says 'Fraueninsel' over the loudspeaker.
A slightly smaller island than Herreninsel.
The ferry is docking. We have arrived.

The monastery on Fraueninsel seen from the ferry.
Here too is a whitewashed monastery building close to the ferry dock. Less imposing than the men's, but friendly, welcoming. And alive. The nuns are still here.
There is life on Fraueninsel. Lots of life.
The nuns, the permanent residents and quite a few visitors.
The island is relatively small and manageable.
I estimate that a walk around the island takes about fifteen minutes – at a slow pace.
The nuns here belong to the Benedictine order.
Which was founded 1500 years ago by Benedict of Nursia, and is an order that includes both monks and nuns.
A traditional life of prayer, work and community is lived here. This has been practiced here on the island since the 12th century. By nuns.
The current abbess is the fifty-sixth in line.
We are Scandinavians.
In the Nordic countries, monastic life has been discontinued since the Reformation.
Whether we define ourselves as believers or not, our culture is marked by Luther's complicated relationship to monastic life – and to deeper inner practice.
Luther believed that one can do nothing for one's own spirituality.
The nuns on Fraueninsel completely disagree with this.
They radiate that they live with deep integrity.
There is no doubt about that when you meet them.
They live by Saint Benedict's basic advice about what is central in life: Pray and work.. To pray and to work.
You can feel and see it in the care they put into the monastery garden and courtyard. There are crops for the kitchen, endless flowers, seating areas in the shade of old trees that invite quiet contemplation. It's as if there is presence in every detail.
The nuns live in accordance with the three 'eternal vows' – they own nothing, they live in celibacy, and they have renounced their own will – they live in total obedience to the abbess.
At least in principle –
Here we encounter a cross for the modern way of life: How, we think, is it to give up private property rights, perhaps the most fundamental right under nation-states, under democracy?
What is it like to give up the right to self-determination – to have and express one's own will and opinion?
And what is it like to live in celibacy without experiencing sexuality?
A few of the nuns on Fraueninsel have chosen to go into lifelong retreat and live their entire lives behind the cloister. Which is the physical and psychological boundary that protects the innermost rooms and enclosed gardens of the monastery. These nuns never go outside.
They have dedicated their lives to God and to the pervasive regularity of tradition.
In Benedict's rule, the core values – in addition to praying and working, and of course this with the three 'eternal vows' – are hospitality and community. That is why we also meet nuns who have chosen a freer version of monastic life where they can take care of the outward-facing side of the monastery, host visitors and handle external communication.
But even these more extroverted people live according to the rhythm of the place:
Every morning at five o'clock the church bells call to prayer.
If you live at the monastery, you may be lucky enough to hear the nuns' morning song. It sounds as if the angels themselves have formed a choir.
At vespers, at sunset, they gather again in the chapel for prayer and singing.
During the day they have their own personal prayer practice and their work tasks, where they each in their own way take care of the old buildings and cultivate the garden and the flower mandalas.
Most of the times I have taught here, we have been given permission to teach in the library.
It is located just outside the cloister, close to the nuns' private chapel, from which the fervor of singing and prayer permeates the long, resounding corridors, the thick walls and the ventilation shafts.
If you visit the island's always-open church at vespers, you can also hear the singing flowing down from the church ceiling. The chapel behind the cloister adjoins the ceiling of the church room. So even though not all the nuns are visible to outsiders, their singing is audible.
- The church door and worn-out door step.
- The church room in the open church.
In the encounter with that song, with the beauty and depth that flows from both the visible nuns and those who are immersed behind the cloister, there is an opportunity to feel into one's own attitude towards monastic life.
For me, there is something special and moving about this direct encounter with life as a nun.
Moving in several ways.
On the one hand, this reminds me of my own gratitude for the individual freedom of being a lay practitioner; it wouldn't suit me to live completely so confined. Not for my whole life.
On the other hand, I am moved by the calm and kindness that the nuns radiate. Moved by how clearly it becomes here on Fraueninsel, how high a price we pay for our lives in modernity. How many strains our individual finances, the joys and sorrows of our relationships, our way of putting ourselves through the world, how great a strain these projects place on us.
The nuns here are, strange as it may sound, also freer than many of us lay people are. They have laid aside a burden, a yoke. They have entered into freedom from having to think, from having to desire, and from having to manage property.
And this is felt and said by an outsider – who has not tried being a nun herself.
How is monastic life experienced from the inside?
What does absolute obedience cost for the feeling of being personally valued and respected?
What does it mean to let go of lived-out sexuality and worldly love?
And is it possible to give up all ownership of personal items as well?
- The monastery yard.
- Group work at Mind&Life symposium.
For many years, Fraueninsel has been a meeting place for researchers in contemplative science and practitioners from all religions.
Martijn and I are here for the fifth time now, to handle part of the contemplative program of this rather extensive event.
Every time I've been here, I've thought I'd write a little about this place.
To try to express the concern I experience here.
To try to share the atmosphere of this unique place with those of you who follow us in Kontemplation.
What made the difference now, that I thought I had to tell you now, was that one of the researchers in the Mind&Life network recently showed me statistics on how many new nuns have been added to Europe and the United States in recent years.
It's a steep downward curve, a drastically decreasing number.
Those already ordained are getting old – and the new ones coming in are too few for the tradition to be carried on.
When I see this development documented, when I feel my love for, and respect for, this way of life, I can feel that now I must share a little bit of life on Fraueninsel with you. While the monastery there still exists and is operational.
The first person you meet when you arrive at the monastery gate is Sister Scholastica. She is friendly and welcoming in a firm and determined manner and inspires immediate respect.
So here we encounter an image that the principled obedience in the eternal promises need not limit an individual's self-reliant authority.
Sister Scholastica is in charge of the monastery's external communications and is responsible for welcoming guests. She has lived here for 30 years, but is originally from Canada, and is fluent in English, German and French.
She's not someone to be trifled with. I imagine she can make almost anyone behave properly.
But once you get inside the gate and get a little more time with her, it's inevitable to feel the warmth behind the firmness.
The warmth and her deep love for the monastery and Fraueninsel.
She accommodates us in the part of the monastery where nuns no longer live. And every year she remembers which room each of the guests in our group usually stays in.
Every time I get the same small cell in the attic, right up under the roof. With sloping walls and a view of the garden and the lake.
I love this room. Simple. And somehow with room for everything you could want.
In that room I clearly feel the pull of simplification. I feel the deeper freedom of nun life.
Once hundreds of women lived here. Nuns and novices. Now the guest section fills more than the nuns' cells.
The building complex is extensive. With several sections on several floors, labyrinthine and enigmatic. With wide staircases and dark corridors decorated with dark paintings of former abbesses who keep an eye on the passerby. With a library and several small chapels and contemplative rooms that call for prayer and devotion. Rooms, corridors and staircases that open up to beautiful inner courtyards and to small, well-kept flower gardens.
A small universe.
It makes perfect sense that you could live your entire life here. If that's what feels right.
- Flower mandala in one of the monastery's courtyards.
- The dome of the bell tower.
The nuns are therefore not completely isolated in several ways.
The monastery is traditionally a place where people in need can stay and be safe. Among other things, the nuns welcome children from war-torn countries who have flown to Germany to have life-saving operations that cannot be performed in their home country. Sometimes they also take care of orphans.
During one of my visits here, I met a seven-year-old boy from Syria who had had a leg amputated after a bombing in which he also lost his parents. He lived with the nuns for a while with his older sister to recover and learn how to move in the world.
The following year, the nuns took care of an Iranian girl who had undergone heart surgery in a German hospital.
The first time I visited Fraueninsel, I met a young woman who had come here to rehabilitate from heavy drug abuse. She was worn out and considered the convent her last chance. She is still here, and has now become Sister Scholastica's right hand. Wearing a kind of informal novice habit, but without being ordained. On the hottest days you can catch a glimpse of her tattooed arms under her summer dress. She looks happy and healthy, and works both high and low throughout the area. She says she has found a home.
There are also private households on the island. Many of those who live here are artists or craftsmen who make a living from their own small gallery or workshop sales. For visitors to the island there are cafes and a couple of fish restaurants. The monastery makes a living from its guests and from events. Like this Mind&Life symposium that I am here for.
And the local lay people live off the tourists who visit the monastery.
They know that the island and its history are something special.
And they take great care of that.
Every little island house, every little garden, every pier and little path is extraordinarily well-kept. And in the middle of the island, two large oak trees unfold. They are 800 years old and stand as a natural sanctuary that goes hand in hand with the history of the monastery.

Benedictine nun Sister Scholastica and Matthieu Ricard, monk in the Tibetan Gelug tradition.
At the first session of the seminar, Sister Scholastica welcomes us all and tells us about the monastery and the island. The group here with Mind&Life is about 60 participants, primarily from Europe, but also from Asia and the USA, and consists of both researchers, lay practitioners and ordained from other traditions.
Sister Scholastica knows that we are gathered here with meditative practice as our focus. In her welcoming speech, she invites us to discover the island in silence. 'For us who live here, the sisters and me,' she says, 'the island itself is our meditation. Perhaps it can also become yours while you are here.'’
With this welcome I become aware of the reason for some of the concern I feel: For me, the dogmatic side of Christianity has always been difficult. Yes, the dogmatic side of any of the world religions. But in Scandinavia, it is Christianity in particular that we have in our lives – in our hearts.
Sister Scholastica is solidly grounded in her own Catholicism. But she does not exude dogmatism. She exudes the Christian compassion and tolerance that are what I perceive as crucial in the inner part of the Christian message of love.
Something in me fervently wishes that there will always be nuns on Fraueninsel. That there will be nuns and monks in many places. That the song and the fervor and mystery of monastic life will live on.
And at the same time, I can feel and understand how difficult it will be.
I wonder whether the current, somewhat gloomy development of the monastic system will mean that in the future we will need lay monasteries to carry out this function.
I have expressed this to my friend, Michael Stubberup, from the Growth Center, who has a deep knowledge of and love for the Eastern Church in particular. He says that when he has turned the situation around in dialogue with monks and nuns from different traditions, they unanimously say that perhaps the greatest challenge in relation to modern society is the requirement of celibacy.
’'If,' Michael says, a senior monk at the Chevetogne monastery in Chinay, Belgium, told him, 'we cannot reach the young, the monastic movement will disappear.'’
’'And the young people,' the monk continued, 'they ask us about relationships, they ask about sexuality, they ask about worldly love. And about the relationship of this love to the experience of God. And we don't know what to answer them, because we ourselves don't know anything about that kind of love.'’
There are also monasteries where they have – cautiously – experimented with having both monks and nuns. What I have also experienced myself at the Valaam monastery on Lake Ladoga, in the Russian part of Karelia. But even in these places the requirement of celibacy is absolute.
I once heard an influential spiritual teacher with in-depth knowledge of the esoteric part of the Christian tradition, its inner side, answer a question about what she thought was needed for the monastic movements to be able to propose and offer an alternative to the absolute requirement of celibacy.
She thought for a long time. Then she said:
’'There will have to be a person who reaches a very deep state of practice along the Christian path – and who then takes this high state with him into a love relationship that also unfolds physically. And thus sets an image of realized Christian mysticism grounded in sexuality.'’
And then she added:
’'It will require a church reformer greater than Grundtvig – so it won't be easy'.
Photo: Betty Jones and Hanneli
is a meditation teacher, psychotherapist and cand.arch.
She founded Kontemplation in 2010 based on an interest in integrating inner practice into everyday life, community, and creative expression.
Hanneli lives at the Growth Center in Nørre Snede, where she is part of the center's regular teaching group.
She is also affiliated with the Children's Life Knowledge Association and has worked with contemplative practice in teaching and creative contexts for many years.







Thank you so much for this loving description of the monastery and the island. It sounds like paradise.
Makes me want to visit the island and the monastery myself.
It brings joy to read your words, thank you for reading, or listening, along. And for telling us what it awakens in you. 🙏
Thank you for a beautifully and respectfully described little glimpse into another world 🙏 I love that there are so many infinite ways to live your life 🥰 I wanted to visit the island and experience it.
Thank you for your words and your empathy – it brings a smile to my face. Yes, isn't it incredibly inspiring with all the many ways we can live our lives? 🙏
Thank you to Hanneli for a wonderful trip to Fraueninsel, and a time travel into a universe far back in our history <3
Dear Karen,
Thank you very much for listening with empathy.
Warm greetings from us in the team, we will pass on your words.
Thanks to Hanneli for taking me (us) to Fraueninsel.
The beautiful way you describe the island and life there makes me feel like I was in the backpack.
The post speaks to so much – that it can be a wealth to own only the most necessary things and still be able to share with others.
Women's Day, March 8, also came to mind…….
The world could learn a lot from such a visit 🙏
Dear Mona, thank you very much for your empathy and the thoughts you share with us. It brings joy. We will pass your words on to Hanneli. Warm greetings from us in the team.