THE SUSTAINABLE WELFARE SOCIETY #1
of | Sustainability and leadership with heart, CULTURE & VIEWS | October 10, 2020
NEXT BIG STEP IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE WELFARE SOCIETY
The book and party program Future Denmark from 1945 was a script for the development of the welfare and competition state. It was a unique social thinking, but it resulted in an unsustainable society in many ways. Now we must have created a script for the development of a sustainable welfare society. What does a sustainable welfare society – and a sustainable world – look like?
The Denmark of the Future – a party program
In the winter of 1944, the then 30-year-old office manager was on the Labour Movement's Business Council. Jens Otto Krag in an apartment in Copenhagen and wrote the book and party program: "The Denmark of the Future. The Politics of the Social Democracy". In November, he had become secretary of the Socialization Committee; a committee originally set up by the Social Democracy after the First World War, and now re-established with the task of formulating the party's work program for the post-war period and the parliamentary elections that would come when the Second World War was about to end. The chairman of the committee was Alsing Andersen, and it consisted of, among others, Vilhelm Buhl, Hans Hedtoft, HC Hansen and many more. A total of 34 members participated when the committee met for the first time on 24 November 1944 in the Karl Marx Hall in the House of People in Copenhagen. You can read about this committee and its work in Bo Lidegaard's excellent two-volume work on JO Krag (1914-1978).
Denmark of the future was already then, and is clearly also in retrospect, a very interesting publication, written at a time when there was war in the world and when Denmark was occupied; there was a lot of poverty and great social inequality. Despite that, it is a book, not just about something else, but about a quite another society – and another world. The word welfare state does not appear in the book, but the book was in fact a description of what became the welfare state, a state and a society that no one had ever seen. And it was also in fact an introductory description of the later so well-known competitive state.
It was a book and a work program about production, productivity and competition. A book and a program statement about growth. It couldn't happen fast enough, and the growth that was talked about so much had to be achieved almost at any cost. More social, economic and cultural equality and justice had to be ensured. Political and economic democracy had to be developed. The importance of business for achieving more economic and material growth and welfare for the large population groups was emphasized. A fairer distribution of society's resources and goods had to be ensured, and the foundation had to be created for more democratic and real access to all kinds of education for many more people. In short. It was about the development of the welfare society that JO Krag was concerned with, and in which he – perhaps more than any other individual – came to play a leading role. But no one talked about sustainability. There was no reason for that. Anything was possible.
Visionary future thinking – a script
It is not difficult to imagine all these phenomena today, but one must remember that this was thought and written at a time when everything in the world – and in Denmark – was completely different. It was truly bold and visionary future thinking of a very special kind. You can read The Denmark of the Future online; when the book and work program were published at the time, it was a small, thin book with a blue cover and red letters. The program was adopted at the Social Democratic Party congress in August 1945 and presented as part of the Social Democratic Party program at the first parliamentary election after the war, an election that was held on October 30, 1945. This first election after the war led, as is well known, to the Liberal Party forming a government, and Knud Kristensen becoming Prime Minister.
The Denmark of the Future is in fact a kind of script for the social development that took place in Denmark (and in Scandinavia) in the rest of the 20th century. A fantastic and bold vision of the future. It was a feat of strength to think of this possible new world. And a new world it was; it was a harbinger of possible completely new times. And already in 1947 the Social Democrats were given the opportunity to form the first social democratic government after the Second World War. Hans Hedtoft became Prime Minister, and JO Krag became Minister of Trade, Industry and Shipping. He was the youngest minister in the government. And so began the realization of some of the visions in The Denmark of the Future.
Marshall Aid – EP Productivity Project
At that time, in 1947, the US Secretary of State had George Marshall gave a famous speech in which he announced the United States' economic reconstruction aid to the European countries, what would later be known as Marshall aid and as Marshall money. JO Krag, as minister, helped administer this money in Denmark. The money was to be used for the three words mentioned above: production, productivity and competition. Out of the total of approximately 13 billion dollars that the United States contributed to the reconstruction of Europe in the years after the war, Denmark received 385 million dollars. It was as part of this entire economic arrangement that the OEEC, the Organization for European Economic Co-operation, was formed in 1948 – and, later, in 1961, transformed into OECD, Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development.
Ministry of Trade Productivity Committee
A central part of the political initiatives that were to contribute to the implementation of some of the thinking in Future Denmark in practice was the so-called Ministry of Commerce Productivity Committee, which was set up by JO Krag in 1949. It consisted of civil servants, researchers and representatives from the trade union movement and the business community. It was to come to symbolise much of the political, managerial and business thinking and practice that came to characterise many of the efforts in Denmark in the following years. The period from 1945 until the 1970s has subsequently been called ’The 30 Glorious Years”. And people have even spoken of a productivity movement. Management and productivity were key words. It was not business, i.e. production, as usual. One should not just continue to work and produce, as one had done in the years leading up to the Second World War. One should get much more out of the resources – and that was achieved to a large extent. Increased productivity was the key word.
The competition state was probably founded here in reality. The Denmark of the Future and the Productivity Committee were competition state phenomena. Seen in that light, it is interesting to study what the productivity committee's task was and how it was solved. You can read about this in a book by Gyldendal, which was published in 2013 as one of 12 books in the series: The Danish Management Canon, and which I helped edit. The book about the Ministry of Trade's Productivity Committee was actually created at my suggestion, because I thought and still do think that it was a very important and interesting management initiative, of which JO Krag was a central part. In fairness, it must be said that the initiative was created at the suggestion (or demand) of the American government, but the implementation was Danish and very successfully implemented. The book is called: "The Productivity Committee. Management as a growth engine".
The committee believed that some crucial factors for raising Danish productivity were: the spread of new technology, knowledge of rational business management, management training, employee training, access to raw materials and materials, and collective wage agreements. The Productivity Committee was to, among other things, conduct courses and study trips to the USA. This resulted in 256 trips for a total of 1,191 participants. Welfare was to be created. Growth in production was the key to prosperity, welfare, development, more education, pensions, holidays, health, etc. And we got it all – and more. The Danish welfare society developed at speeds and in ways that even Krag probably would not have had the imagination to imagine in the first post-war years. But it happened. And it was fantastic.
1957 – a key year for the development of the welfare state
Former senior scholar, professor emeritus Niels Kærgaard wrote an interesting article (Kristeligt Dagblad, October 23, 2019) about this development in Denmark. The article was titled: ”1957 was a key year in the history of the welfare state”. In the chronicle, Niels Kjærgaard discusses the political development in Denmark in the post-war years, including in particular the formation of the government in 1957, which led to the formation of the famous Triangle Government. Niels Kjærgaard's point is that with the formation of this government, the way was paved for the subsequent many years of development of the welfare society, of which the Socialization Committee in the Future of Denmark had drawn the first and very clear contours. It is clear that the first steps, as indicated, had already been taken in the previous years, but with the Triangle Government the line becomes clearer and more manifest.
The Future Denmark and the Triangle Government, in which JO Krag was also a minister (Minister of Foreign Affairs and later Minister of Foreign Affairs), were concerned with a lot, but not with sustainability. Quite the opposite, you could almost say. They were concerned with production and productivity – almost with the headline: Cost whatever it costs. Marshall funds were flowing into Europe in those years, and they had to be used. They had to be rationalized, standardized, streamlined, mechanized and automated. And that was it. In the telephone directories of the time there was a term called Rationalization Expert. These were engineers and others who worked to create more efficient production processes in all kinds of companies. They were concerned with the efficient operation of companies. The more, the better. The faster, the better. Productivity. Production. Competitiveness. Growth. Prosperity. The line was clear. The many study trips and courses worked.
Illustration: Daniel Sebastian Hoeg
Steen Hildebrandt
born 1944, PhD and professor at the Department of Management, Aarhus School of Business, Aarhus University. Formerly a member of the National Council of Competence and management editor at the daily newspaper Børsen. He is the author of books, articles and columns on management and social issues and is a member of several boards of directors.