THE SUSTAINABLE WELFARE SOCIETY, PART 2.
Click here to read first part
Our Stone Hildebrandt tells sore
the prelude to Jens Otto Krag's visionary
– and for understandable reasons limited –
formulation of a playbook for the welfare state.
An unsustainable development
But! And in retrospect after rationalization, there is a big But. It was an unsustainable development that was initiated and practiced. We did not see it so clearly along the way, but it was not a sustainable society that we developed. The concept of sustainability was not part of the conceptual world of Future Denmark – nor of that time. The basic idea here was quite different, namely: There are enough resources. It is about utilizing them – for the good of the people. In a democratic way. It was not the resources of the planet and sustainability that were the problem or the challenge. In reality, and for easily understandable reasons, people thought very narrowly. Nature was there; the resources were there; there was air and water, oil and coal in abundant quantities; such abundant quantities were there that air and water were used in economic textbooks for many decades as examples of free goods, i.e. goods that did not need to be economized with, because there were abundant quantities of them – they did not need a price. You could just use it up. And you did. This use-it-up thinking is still the dominant one. We treat nature's resources as if there were unlimited amounts of them; we abuse nature to an extent and in ways that you wouldn't have thought possible. We still do that, but now we talk about sustainability. We still talk more than we act, and this is hopefully and probably the beginning of more action.
Productivity Commission
As late as 2012, when the then Productivity Commission was established and began issuing its analyses and recommendations, it was not sustainability, but old-fashioned production and productivity that was still the focus. The terms of reference stated, among other things: ”If the current weak productivity development continues, there is a significant risk that Denmark will lose further ground compared to other prosperous countries and will therefore have difficulty maintaining private and public welfare of an internationally high quality.” The conservative government and the commission were concerned with a simple old-fashioned economic growth race. Not with sustainability. I almost said: They were not concerned with sustainability at all. I was invited by the commission to write an article that was published on the commission’s website. I gave my article the title: Sustainable productivity. The Commission maintained throughout a traditional and well-documented concept of productivity, which we now have to discuss again – in light of the knowledge that we also had at the time about the necessity of a transition to more sustainable production. Today, manufacturing companies all over the world are concerned with how to work ever more sustainably. Sustainable productivity and production. And it is happening.
From 1957 until now, an incredible amount has happened in Denmark – and in the world. Technological and demographic development has exploded. Production and productivity as well. In Denmark and in the world. In 60 years, the world has become different. The world is today in a completely new situation. On the positive side: The main theme is not just welfare and prosperity, but sustainable welfare and prosperity. The challenge is not growth, but sustainable growth. The challenge is not production and productivity, but sustainable production and productivity. On the negative side: Nationalism and isolationism: New serious risk images are emerging with great force, and the world is in many ways and areas on a very dangerous course.
Side effects
In retrospect: It happened too quickly. We were not sufficiently aware of the series of unintended and therefore also long-unnoticed side effects of our busyness and determination, not to mention our greed. I am not criticizing the decisions and the worldview that lay behind these decisions. I note that these are new times. And I allow myself to assert – in agreement with many others, both ordinary citizens, researchers, politicians, artists and others: It is urgent to make a new worldview a reality. We know it. We know that the challenge is sustainability, and the UN's 17 global goals, the sustainability goals, point to clear areas of action. But what are the states doing? What are we consumers and citizens doing?
Some of what has happened in the intervening 60 years is: A new awareness has emerged, new insights have been developed. Something new was already evident in 1972, when the report Limits to Growth drew attention to the fact that there are limits to growth, limits to production, limits to our development and ambitions. The book, Rebellion from the Middle by the authors Villy Sørensen, Niels I. Meyer and K. Helveg Petersen from 1978 and the Brundtland report, Our Common Future, from 1987 also warned. They clearly drew attention to some of these questions and themes. And, yes, in fairness, it should also be remembered that JO Krag, in his third government, in 1971, established the world's first Ministry for Public Works and Pollution Control with Jens Kampmann as minister. Which was again an expression of Krag's foresight and great political abilities and leadership.
The new great challenge: Sustainability
But still: We didn’t listen or didn’t listen thoroughly enough back then. Now we know that the next big challenge in the development of the Danish welfare society is not growth and production, but sustainability. It is tempting to ask – with reference to Niels Kærgaard’s headline: Will we say around 2050 that 2019, when Denmark – just like in 1957 – also got a new government – and a new climate law, was the key year in the history of the sustainable welfare society? Is 2020 the year when the awareness of sustainability really changes and finds its way into all the cracks and becomes the new agenda or at least an important element in more and more new agendas?
We are allowed to fantasize and ask questions, and my assumption and hope is that it will happen. 2020 – and the years around it – are becoming the years when sustainability, among other things strongly influenced by the UN's 17 global goals, the Brundtland thinking and much else – will become the big and overarching theme and the new agenda. And therefore these are also the years when the welfare society will be further developed, but in new directions. Or to be more precise: the welfare society must be transformed and rethought. We must develop a new kind of welfare society. A sustainable welfare society. And once again, Denmark can show the way – or help to show the way.
Illustration: Daniel Sebastian Hoeg
Steen Hildebrandt
born 1944, PhD and professor at the Department of Management, Aarhus School of Business, Aarhus University. Formerly a member of the National Council of Competence and management editor at the daily newspaper Børsen. He is the author of books, articles and columns on management and social issues and is a member of several boards of directors.