Reflexive conflict mediation and sustainability

Konfliktmaegling_Daniel

There are many mediation models, each with its own characteristics. As a rule, however, the ethical basis behind the different mediation models is not made clear, often not even made conscious.[iii] This means that the criterion for when a mediation is successful is generally limited to whether the parties have reached an agreement, and not to considerations such as whether the mediator has included his or her own opinion on how the conflict should be resolved – and if so, whether it is acceptable – and whether the parties have also had the opportunity to improve the relationship.

Mediation is confidential, and if the parties reach an agreement, it cannot be appealed. While the parties have more influence over the resolution of their conflict than they would have in a court case, for example, they also forgo the protection against manipulation and abuse of power that access to a public courtroom or the possibility of appeal would have afforded them.

Therefore, the requirement of voluntariness and confidentiality in mediation is far from sufficient to replace the protection provided in the legal system.

It goes without saying that mediators, who do not have legal rules to adhere to in the same way as, for example, a judge, are confronted to a very large extent with their own ideas about right and wrong.

Since mediation takes place in a closed room, the necessity for the mediator to be aware of his/her responsibility and his/her attitude towards life, and to carry out his/her mediation in respect of this, therefore becomes urgent if the process is to be transparent.

It was against this background. As a lawyer, I was trained in what are called 'legal guarantees' (such as publicity, always joint meetings, evidence assessment and access to appeal), which are procedures that I have great respect for. The guarantees were developed at the time to counteract the possible abuses that a person in authority with great power could risk exposing people to. In my opinion, it is and was an impressive – and vigilant – way of taking into account human fallibility.

But what do you do when, as in mediation, you remove those guarantees? What is the bulwark against abuse, whether it is done intentionally or negligently?

While I was – and am – excited about the qualities of mediation, I could also see its pitfalls.

No matter how much the mediator is trained in specific tools and techniques that are consistent with the underlying values, the mediator's deeper motivations will come through if she comes under pressure. This happens whether the pressure is due to the parties being particularly combative, time being tight, or the mediator having a bad day. Therefore, the mediator needs to first become aware of her own view of humanity and society and then constantly confront herself with the extent to which her practice is consistent with this.

The mediator owes this continuous self-examination to the parties in respect of the trust they show by asking the mediator for help. She owes it to the mediation process in respect of the formlessness that is the hallmark (and vulnerability) of mediation. And she owes this persistent internal examination to herself in respect of the integrity that must be the mediator's strength and anchor, even in difficult situations during the mediation process.

This point of view has far-reaching consequences for both mediation training and practice: First, it presupposes an explicit value base[iv], and second, that the mediator continuously considers the extent to which the same value base unfolds in her practice.

Conflict mediation with such a reflexive approach is characterized by being eclectic – but not in the sense that anything is allowed as long as it works. It is eclectic because it is possible to be inspired by already known mediation models and to include elements of these in practice, as The crucial thing for mediation according to this model is the values that motivate the mediator and on which they work during the mediation. Neither more nor less.

This means that conflict mediation with a reflexive approach is not something external, like a cloak that can be taken off and put on, but rather something internal, some values that are integrated and that are present with the mediator both in and outside the mediation. Values that the mediator must continuously take a responsible approach to. The individual mediator must then come to terms with himself or herself whether the values and assumptions on which reflexive mediation is based are in harmony with his or her own, and if necessary choose a different form of mediation.

With the help of philosophy, we can roughly divide people – and probably also mediators – into two categories according to our view of humanity: One group believes in the fundamental goodness of humans and sees the evil in the world as caused by, for example, social inequality or a repressive society. The other group believes that people are generally born selfish, and that empathy and love for others are cultivated through socialization[v].

These two views of humanity testify that there is hardly one objective truth about human nature. However, philosophy gives us a clue that different views of humanity, implicit or explicit, can underlie our actions and assumptions.

In reflective mediation, the view of humanity is positive, meaning that one believes that with the right upbringing and under the right conditions, humans will act constructively both towards themselves and towards others.

The fact that the right upbringing and the right conditions are rarely present is another matter.

But the point of view expresses a dynamic view of humanity, where the opportunity for personal growth and insight is always present, and a conviction that within every human being there is a core of purity and love.

In the preface to An essay on inner freedom From 2010, Jes Bertelsen writes the following:

”We need to realize that external and internal changes are interconnected. We cannot establish a better external world without changing the internal one. You cannot change the life of a person – or a nation – by changing external conditions alone. Nor can you do it by changing internal conditions alone. But since the world we live in focuses primarily on external, physical reality and thus away from the bodies and hearts and consciousnesses that the changes fundamentally affect, it is the aim of this book to draw attention to the overlooked, but indispensable, component of a comprehensive solution to the threatening and promising situation we find ourselves in as a species: the development of a sense of human solidarity.” [we]

The preface describes an understanding of several contexts that have guided me over the years, both professionally and personally, and thus also for reflexive mediation. This applies to both the connection between the inner and the outer and the connection between conflicts at the micro and macro levels.

The mediator, in the reflexive approach, has as its foundation a conviction that human life is most naturally lived in a context where there is room for both the individual and for cohesion.

The reflexive is not only directed at the mediator, but also at the parties. However, it is of course not the intention to impose the underlying values on them, which would be both counterproductive and self-contradictory. The mediator asks the parties questions that challenge their preconceptions – not to change them, but to give the parties a chance to relate to the depth and consequence of their decisions. On this basis, they choose freely.

At the same time, it must be said that the values on which reflexive mediation is based are based on my view that it is necessary for us all to act more appropriately in the future than we have done so far. This implies, among other things, that we are aware of our mutual dependence, both individually and globally, and that we are prepared not only to assert this position, but actually to take on a shared responsibility for it. Only in this way can we contribute to creating a sustainability that is not only local, but global, and thereby also sustainable in a longer perspective.

 

Footnotes:

[iii] However, with one clear exception, namely Baruch Bush and Joe Folger, Transformative mediation, The Promise of Mediation: A Transformative Approach to Conflict, Jossey-Bass, 2005

[iv] The value basis is described in detail in Conflict Mediation – a Reflexive Model, to which reference is made.
[v] See e.g. Ken Wilber, Up from Eden, A Transpersonal View of Human Evolution, Boston 1981 p 331f.

[vi] Jes Bertelsen, An essay on inner freedom, Rosinante 2010

 

Illustration: Daniel Sebastian Høeg, 11 years old


“Reflexive conflict mediation and sustainability” has been edited and organized for Kontemplation’s blog. The text was first published as part of Vibeke Vindeløv’s contribution to the article series Spirit in Everyday Life.


 

Vibeke Vindeløv
is a lawyer, psychotherapist and professor of conflict mediation at the Faculty of Law, University of Copenhagen. She is the author of several articles and books on law, mediation and reconciliation. She has extensive experience in teaching and practical work with conflict resolution and mediation in a variety of conflict types. She is interested in the connection between value and action and the large and small conflict. Geographical focal points for her international work have been Southeastern Europe (Balkans) and South Africa.

 

 

FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM

Follow on Instagram
Follow on Instagram