Presence and design processes
of | COMMUNITY & RELATIONSHIPS, Internal practice and working life | April 27, 2018
I have participated in the Training in Relationship Competence – Presence and Empathy. This text is about teaching design to asylum-seeking children and how presence is important for this practice.
Monday workshop in design for asylum-seeking children at Designmuseum Denmark.
I am sitting in the Design Workshop. In front of me is a large table. The table is filled with materials. And around it are 15 young middle and high school students from the Red Cross School, aged 13-16. They are making chair models and small rooms that will fit the chair. They have been told that they must make a chair and a room for it. Just as they want.
Your room. Your chair.
I observe. I just try to see. Without intervening. It's not an easy exercise for me. Just observing.
I'm usually a teacher. I guide. I ask questions. I help. I organize. I have an overview. That's my role.
But not right now. Right now I'm the researcher. I'm just trying to see. From a "neutral" place. But my mind wanders. I see all the wires from the glue guns. Besides everything. Paper. Wood veneer. Scissors. Cutting mat. Hobby knives. Textiles in all sorts of colors. Felt.
When the young people arrived, everything was neatly arranged on the materials table. Now it's all over the place. In bits. In stacks. And it all hums with preoccupation and immersion. The teachers go around helping. They are with those who get stuck or have difficulty with something. Everyone is busy and there is a very concentrated atmosphere. And then there is something else. Something that I have not felt in this way before. With all the children I have taught and seen work. There is also a very special restlessness. Both calm and restlessness.

In a way, what is happening is completely normal. And at the same time, it is a completely abnormal situation. Because the young people in front of me don't know where they are going to live. They don't know their immediate future. They come from a reality I can't imagine. They live in asylum centers where they can't cook for themselves. It's part of their daily life. They live in rooms with their parents. They are asylum seekers.
So I feel very conflicting emotions. Abandonment. In spite. And then again the fascination with what is happening right in front of me. All that will to live in the young people. Will to want something. Even though life has fallen apart.

But, I say to myself, right now they are here. They are accomplishing something. One model after another is taking shape. How can that be? How can it be that making a model can capture their attention in the way that it actually does?
I start to notice their hands. And then it suddenly becomes clear to me that the work of their hands with the materials seems to hold them in place. As if the rest of their bodies could start jumping or running. It's as if their hands are anchoring them to the table. Anchoring them in what they're doing.
I can see hands from several people collaborating without a verbal language. Hands reaching out. Putting something together. Bodies getting up and picking up scissors. Feeling the materials. Senses. My focus becomes their hands, suddenly it's so exciting for me to look at their hands. All that's going on. As if the table is like a big anthill of quite precise activity. Like a simultaneity of order and chaos.
Helle Jensen describes in the book "”Pedagogical relationship competence” presence as different forms of attention.
One form of attention is described as ”intentional will-directed attention”. For children with diagnoses, this form of attention is important to learn because many of these children are easily disturbed and can react strongly to minor events around them. Training the ability to be present can help them to stay focused and be immersed over longer periods of time. This requires ongoing interaction with adults who are interested in exploring and investigating the world with the child. Lack of one-on-one contact with adults is the reason why many ordinary children do not develop this attention at an early age. This has implications for the ability later in life to ”metacognitive control”. (Jensen 2104) Metacognitive control is the ability to pay attention to one’s own attention. Without this ability, the child cannot bring attention ”home” when it begins to wander. The ability to do this can be strengthened by teaching a targeted focus on alternating between activities that require outward and inward attention. It is often the case that inward activity is under-prioritized. But training this can lead to greater integration of what is called ”integrated meta-attention.” (Jensen 2014) This is defined by the child's ability to notice themselves, their own states and thus be able to develop self-insight and self-reliance.
Another form of attention is ”broad, comprehensive and active attention”. This is characterised by not focusing on anything in particular. It can be important during a busy school day. It is about learning to be able to stop and become aware of whether you are paying attention at all. Being able to stop in this way is a prerequisite for developing presence. Presence is important because presence is a fundamental prerequisite for being able to establish and be in contact with others. Being able to be present with yourself and the person(s) you are with requires that you are in contact with your own empathy, judgement and, for the professional, also your professional knowledge.
The pedagogy that supports these forms of attention can consist of establishing a space in which topics and investigations can unfold in all their complexity. That an environment is created where all answers are not given in advance, and where students are allowed to experiment and explore. The teaching can create the framework for immersion and allow students a form of self-forgetfulness in a judgment-free space that can accommodate both flow and frustrations. The intention is then that the framework provides so much security that it can actually strengthen the students' experiences with, and experiences of, that they have skills and that they are allowed to express themselves; that their statements have validity. It is about establishing a meeting between the students' own background and the direction of pedagogy towards experienced creativity. A meeting that - at best - opens two worlds towards each other. Based on a desire to create teaching that students can see themselves in, and that feels relevant to them. The teaching must seek to make sense of the whole paradox of trying to create a ”normal” framework for teaching a group of students who do not know their immediate future in relation to very basic things such as knowing where to live. It is thus also about a pedagogy that has a caring side.
The pictures below show a process where a boy from the middle school uses his sketch as a template to draw a new sketch which then becomes the template for the chair model he is making. He is in a design process. The picture shows a concentration and immersion that also takes place for the students in moments.

The two image sequences show how hands spontaneously work together, and you can see how the hands know what to do. It was very fascinating to observe these two boys. There were not many words between them. But they communicated physically. And they had a common goal of making a model of an urban space together.
Design is an aesthetic enterprise that involves the designer in the design process collecting and creating background knowledge, sorting, sketching, inventing, testing and finally mediating his ideas via form, words and images. It is this process that we aim to establish for the students when they are taught in the design workshop at the museum. The design workshop is responsible for the practical creative part of the museum's teaching. Here the students themselves enter the design process when the task is, for example, to produce a model of a chair.

Being in a creative process is also being in a process that includes both success and adversity. Sometimes it flows, other times you can come to a complete standstill. It is these processes and their changing nature that we would like to help students experience. The goal is for them to get to know themselves. The fact that you can make ”mistakes” is part of the design process, the fact that you try something and accept that it doesn’t work. The fact that something you hadn’t imagined appears and can change the entire process along the way. The students gain skills in being able to navigate this unpredictability. During the immersion that lies in building models for the students, the students spontaneously enter into dialogue with each other about form and materials. The creative process thus also unfolds as training for social skills.
Guiding students in the design process can be seen as moving through different spaces. As if each phase is a room followed by several others. In this spatial universe, one does not proceed in a chronologically ordered sequence. One goes both in and out of the rooms and back and forth between them. The process can be described as looking for something that one does not yet know what it is. This search for something takes place as an alternation between questions and sensations and answers intertwined with each other and as a progressive process. The young people experience a similar journey, and you can see from them that they have found themselves in such a creative flow that is often wordless when they come beaming with joy and show what they have made. Or frustrated they come and ask what they should do next. The pedagogical space here becomes a guidance meeting between teacher and student. A meeting that is based on presence.
Kirsten Rotbøll Lassen is a visual artist and project manager for Design School at Designmuseum Danmark where she teaches children and adults. She dances, meditates and hikes, and is interested in psychology, philosophy and sustainability. Kirsten is part of the team behind the Relationship Skills Training.
See more about Kirsten's work at the Design School here.



