Meetings in silence, unfamiliar forms of togetherness

Anthropological reflections on an educational course in Empathy and Presence

The sound of a fork against a plate, salad crunching between teeth, a spoon against a bowl of soup, soup hitting a plate, water being poured into a glass, sinking, a chair being moved. The sound of the absence of conversation. The feeling of slight tension between people. Fourteen people to be exact, eating together. Not a word is said, and hardly a glance is exchanged. The fourteen people are not enemies. They are invited to eat together in 'noble silence'.

Between people, silence, or the lack thereof, is a social phenomenon. That's what makes it interesting to an anthropologist.

There are many different forms of silence. Silence can be relaxed and comfortable, but it can also be an expression of passive aggression – a form of protest. Silence can also stem from withdrawal, where it can function as a protective barrier between oneself and the other. Silence can also be a way of showing respect, for example when listening to a friend, a teacher or a stranger – or when everyone is quiet at a memorial service. In short, silence can have an infinite number of meanings.

jl1

In our part of the world, silence in groups of people usually requires an occasion, but in some other societies, silence in social relationships is seen as acceptable behavior. In situations where conversation among people is the norm, silence can be experienced as awkward or downright rude. In Denmark, many people will experience silence in a dining situation just like that; because what – as one participant expressed – do you do when everything you were raised to do no longer applies? To ask for the butter. To say thank you. To ask interestedly about the other person.

It is the first day of module two of the ”Empathy and Presence” training. The module extends over two consecutive days. At Solbakkevej 15 in Nørre Snede, this Saturday we are indirectly investigating some of the landscapes that children and young people in school have to go through during imposed silence. We do this by investigating what, during silence, is happening in our own inner landscapes. In the long term, the hope is that this insight into our inner selves gives us more tools to maneuver appropriately and present in the environments that surround us, and for the participants in particular; in the role of the professional adult in working with children and/or young people.

Module two marks the transition between full focus on one’s own practice (inner work) and the beginning of meeting the outer world more intimately. On this first day, which this post focuses on, seven hours are spent in silence. The first part of the morning the participants exchange their experiences with one’s own practice in the intervening weeks since we first met, just as we are guided through a seated meditation and a yoga session. Then we enter into silence. Or that is to say, Peter and Hanneli guide us verbally through various exercises, but we participants are silent – at least on the outside. Only after dinner is the silence broken again and there is an opportunity to exchange experiences.

jl2

There are places in the world where silence in eating situations and other social contexts is far more widespread than in Denmark. Especially, it seems, among people who live in areas where humans are the fewest creatures. This is the case, for example, among the North American Apache and Beaver peoples, and among the Siberian nomadic peoples such as the Evens and the Chukchi. Anthropologist Piers Vitebsky writes in the book Reindeer People about the silence among the Evens in Yakutia, that it is not awkward: That a handful of people who see no one but each other for months know how to be alone together. The fact that he directly points out that this silence is not awkward shows that he himself has experienced silence as awkward in other situations. I also know that feeling, and probably several of you who are reading this.

The Evens are very attentive to nuances in each other's moods, writes Vitebsky, and wonders whether this attention is more challenged in an environment that is more verbal. He himself describes how over time he learned to tell the difference between when a person left the reindeer camp because he wanted to get away from the others and when he went out to do some work. Just as he learned to sense irritations or warmth between the different tents, without words being expressed. These considerations are interesting in relation to the use of silence as one of the methods for practicing empathy and presence in this education. Vitebsky describes that communication between people in a reindeer camp sometimes takes on what he experiences as an almost telepathic form, where one knows how the other feels without any intermediate words.

Hugh Brody describes in ”Maps and Dreams” how a group of young men from the Beaver people on a hunt can sit for hours without talking. Even movements are minimal; one hand reaching for a cup, another tending the fire. Whatever is expressed in words in these situations is almost imperceptible, he writes, as if the words barely break the silence. It is not a sleepy silence, it is an alert and receptive state. To an outsider it may seem as if the hunters have forgotten where they are. And suddenly, Brody writes, the state changes from quiet to active, as if everyone suddenly realizes that it is time for action. Again, to an outsider, the change is as incomprehensible as when a person watches in amazement a flock of over 1,000 starlings take to the wings at the same second. To an insider, it is a matter of a deep wordless understanding of, and empathy with, their surroundings.

gaaende-meditation-7

I know this from my fieldwork in northern Kamchatka among the Chukchi reindeer nomads. When you are a small group of five people in a circle of several days of migration – surrounded only by Arctic tundra, a few thousand reindeer and a number of other animal species that are hidden from human eyes for a large part of the time – social life takes on different forms. In a special way, you become like a unit. As the female tent worker, I had to develop the ability to read whether the shepherd who comes home from the herd wants his soup immediately, whether he needs tea first, or whether he wants to change his clothes first. Not in a telepathic way, but by paying attention to body language, mood and action. It was rare for the shepherds to ask for soup or tea; it was my job to know when they wanted it and whether they wanted more. Each shepherd had his own way of signaling his wishes.

It's not that there's no talking in these types of communities, but my experience is that there's a (necessary) alertness to the surroundings and thus to each other. In Kamchatka, this was expressed in ways other than through practical community. For example, one morning I was very tired, and when I thought I was alone, I went a little away from the camp to enjoy the sunrise for myself and recharge a little. When I came back, I was surprised to find the camp leader sharpening his knife. I didn't say anything to him, but continued my work where I had left off. "You're tired. It's good that you're feeding your soul with the power of the sun," he said and continued his work. Honestly, I had tried to hide my tiredness, but it was seen. I met his warm gaze with gratitude. There was no need to say anything more.

Based on the knowledge we have from other cultures about silence in interaction with others, and the fact that an education in Empathy and Presence uses silence as a path, I can't help but ask whether our empathic abilities have particularly good conditions for growing in silence? Or is it the increased presence that silence makes possible that brings out the inherent empathic abilities?

gaaende-meditation-kat

And what about 'noble silence', which is what we practice this Saturday in the second module of the training? Noble silence is a concept borrowed from the meditation practices of the Eastern world, and differs from the silence I have described so far in that it involves a total absence of eye contact. Noble silence is often a practice that surrounds a meditative retreat, and this type of silence can help to reinforce the experience of separation from normal social life. The mental energy is concentrated inward and magnified by the lack of extroversion. Yet several who have sat in longer retreats with noble silence describe that they felt a deeper connection with others in the silence. So the greater separation in observable contact due to the absence of both speech and eye contact does not immediately seem to limit the experience of connection from within. My first-hand interpretation of this is that there must be different forms of interpersonal contact: the observable, which can be seen and heard on the surface, and the unobservable, which is invisible to the human eye, but which, to use an expression from The Little Prince, can be seen with the heart.

 

You can't immerse yourself unilaterally, says Hanneli at one point in the middle of the silence. But the initiative can come from one side. The silence in which the day takes place is intended to help the process towards such an initiative. Hanneli further explains that being quiet for a few hours can provide freedom from the slight pressure that often comes from the outside world with the expectation of being communicative most of the time. Immersion requires us to gather our energy, and this can be done, among other things, by learning that our outward engagement in the world is supplemented by this inward listening that silence makes possible. A listening for who we essentially are, and a listening into the present. It is through presence in the present that immersion occurs, says Hanneli.

There is ample opportunity to explore our inner landscape during this day of reflection, not least during lunch and dinner, which are consumed in silence. But also through the guided meditations. Between two walking meditations, we have a sitting meditation that touches me particularly deeply. Peter starts by sketching out the world's current refugee situation, and asks us to contact our heart feelings. We are born compassionate beings, he reminds us, and then retells a powerful story from early 19th century Stavanger, a variation of Terje Vigen. I cannot begin to retell the story here, but a love child and its mother are killed and the father is captured and must serve as a slave on a warship for years. Later, the father is given the opportunity to take revenge, but the love for a foreign innocent child shows him the way to forgiveness. The story, combined with the awareness of all the suffering the world is experiencing, makes me sad. This is exactly where I am challenged because the energy from the emotions is so powerful. This is exactly where I want to share the sorrow and love of my broken heart. I am in despair because I am not sure I would have had the same ability to forgive as the main character in the story, and I suddenly feel very strongly that the future of the planet depends on the human ability to forgive. Surely forgiveness can only be achieved through empathy? Peter's retelling gives me the biggest challenge of the weekend, and in the silence I have to find a way to deal with it. On Sunday, this challenge is transformed into the absolute highlight of the weekend, which I will tell you about in the next blog post.

I am not the only participant who is challenged by the silence. As we cautiously move out of the quiet room in the evening after dinner and re-establish verbal communication, the other participants' challenges, but also positive experiences, finally come to light.

jl3-kopi

The eating situations in particular proved to be challenging for several of the participants. As mentioned earlier, for some, eating in silence gave rise to feelings of discomfort, awkwardness and even rudeness. One participant felt an anonymity that gave a feeling of unreality, like seeing oneself from the outside. The person experienced that it was easier to be in contact with oneself in silence when the body moved, such as in the walking meditations. Several people could recognize this. Some of the participants are normally either very physically active or verbally active. Sitting and doing nothing besides listening to the teachers' voices was challenging. One person put it this way: when the body moves, there is peace inside, and when the body needs to be quiet, there is unrest and a multitude of thoughts inside. It sounds to me as if the power that Hanneli talked about finding in silence can be difficult to contain. A movement or a verbal expression is also a release of accumulated energy.

In this context, it is interesting to think about what is actually asked of children in school. One of the many challenges teachers encounter in connection with teaching is restlessness, children who have difficulty being quiet. It seems that adults also encounter challenges with what is daily demanded of children.

One of the participants shared a paradoxical experience of initially having difficulty containing oneself and one's thoughts in the silence, but then, when the silence finally had to be broken, feeling sad and experiencing that all the voices became overwhelming. This may be related to something several participants said they had experienced, namely that silence can also be a pleasant free space where one does not have to make an effort to be social in the right way, where one does not have to exert effort to fulfill a certain role. A few expressed an experience of security and warmth by being able to be with a group of people and at the same time simply be with oneself.

afrunding

In summary, I can say about today's overall theme, immersion in silence, that although silence could be experienced as a free space, for many it was also a challenge. Both because in this form it is outside the norm in our society, and at the same time because the energy from one's own system grows when there is no opportunity to express oneself.

Something that is really interesting about this educational process, at least from an anthropological point of view, is that it breaks norms in many ways. For example, by 'turning one's gaze inwards' during seven hours of silence. At the same time, it is an education offered by Ikast-Brande municipality, which in this way comes into its own in terms of being norm-creating. Norms are social constructions and are therefore elastic and can change over time. The school – and other institutions that offer courses or other work with children and young people – are in many ways an interface between children, families, society and the state. This makes these institutions and their employees central in terms of communicating the values, expectations and obligations that are contained in being valued citizens in the society in question.

In addition to academic learning, one of the purposes of school is to socialize children into certain culturally recognized forms of behavior. In school, children learn to identify with a specific social community. Subjects such as history, language, and social studies contribute to this socialization process, but informal learning also occurs through the social practices of school teachers and through the organization of the school's social space.

This training course in empathy and presence must be said to be a direct effort against what can be called informal learning through its impact on the social practice of the teacher or educator. However, this social practice is also inextricably linked to the students' opportunity to acquire formal knowledge, as this learning is influenced by the environment in which it takes place. It will be so exciting to follow how, and if, the participants in this training course experience their own social practices changing, and what reflections they receive through this process from their students.

In the next blog post, which focuses on the second day of module 2, there will be much more focus on external and sometimes confrontational communication methods. Not everything is learned through silence.

Inspired by Professor Otto Friedrich Bollnow, I would say that it seems important to examine the relationship between silence and speech in relationships. Bollnow wrote that all speech breaks out of silence and falls back into silence. But what happens in the transitions? What is silence anyway? Can our self-relationship in silence shape what comes out in speech? And if so, how does it affect people's social relationships?

I'm still curious.

Literature:
Bass, Keith. 1996. Wisdom Sits in Places: Landscape and Language Among the Western Apache. University of New Mexico Press.

Bolnow. OF 1982. On silence. Findings of Philosophical-Pedagogical Anthropology. http://search.proquest.com/openview/12bf0938d4ad4e1ee1c7a58f1fd71677/1?pq-origsite=gscholar

Brody, Hugh. 1992 Maps and Dreams: Indians and the British Columbia Frontier. Douglas & McIntyre

de Saint-Exupéry, Antoine 2001. The Little Prince. Lindhardt and Ringhof, Edition: 2

Sørensen, BR, Gilliam, L. and Waltorp, K. 2010. Introduction. School children and citizens of society. In Journal of Anthropology, no. 62: School

Vitebsky, Piers 2005. Reindeer People: Living With Animals and Spirits in Siberia. HarperCollins Publishers

 

Photo: Jeanette Lykkegård, Mads Haagen and Gitte Batz


 

Jeanette LykkegårdJeanette Lykkegaard is a PhD student in Anthropology with a special interest in how people around the world deal with existential questions about life and living it, death and what comes after. In addition to learning new perspectives on the world through my subject, I enjoy, among other things, the smell of earth, the sound of laughter, the sight of a sunrise and the other moments when I feel completely and utterly alive.

 

FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM

Follow on Instagram
Follow on Instagram