Book Review: EMMA JUNG · ANIMUS AND ANIMA

of | Book talker | September 24, 2021

Hanneli - Animus og Anima

BLOGCAST: The post is recorded by Morten Winkler. Listen to the blog here (11:45):

The little book Animus and Anima is a classic in depth psychology's mapping and understanding of the concepts of anima and animus. If you are a psychotherapist or Jungian reading this, you are probably already familiar with it. If the book is unknown to you, you will get what I hope can be an appetite-wheter.

Let me say right away that it is a text I would highly recommend to anyone interested in inner reflection processes.

It is written by the psychoanalyst Emma Jung, based on two lectures she gave in 1931 and 1955, respectively.

Despite the book's age, it is still one of the most precise things ever written about psychological developmental processes regarding the awareness and integration of what is called the opposite sex. That is, the relationship described by Emma Jung's colleague and spouse. Carl Gustav Jung and in both Hinduism, Taoism and Buddhism, that each of us, along with our biological sex, has in our unconscious a number of qualities of the opposite sex. That women, as Taoism puts it, have a man on the inside, and a man correspondingly has a woman on the inside.

Emma Jung's book is, in its own low-key way, a page turner.

Based on CG Jung's in-depth exploration of the structure and content of the unconscious, Emma Jung zooms in on the concept of anima and animus and the role these factors play in the development of personality and as mediators between the conscious and unconscious parts of our psyche.

The term anima covers the inner feminine aspects and development area of the man. Animus, the inner masculine aspects and development potential of the woman.

Since this book was written before the more differentiated understanding of gender in modern times, we relate here to Jung and the depth psychological understanding of the masculine and the feminine as objective qualities available within all people – which our subjective and cultural attachment to our biological sex prevents us from direct access to. But which it is possible to come into contact with through a conscious effort.

Emma Jung writes:

”Two archetypes* in particular have gained great importance because, on the one hand, they belong to the personality and, on the other hand, have roots in the collective unconscious and thus form a kind of link or bridge between the conscious and the unconscious. These two figures – one male and the other female – Jung called Animus and Anima. By this he understands a functional complex that has a compensatory relationship with the outer personality. In a way, one can speak of an inner personality whose characteristics are in contrast to the outer, conscious and manifest personality.

In the man, it is about the feminine qualities and in the woman, the masculine qualities, which are normally always present to a certain extent, but which have not found a place in the outward personality, as they have had a disruptive effect on the external adaptation or the existing ideal.”

(EJ, p. 10)

 

About the nature of the Animus

Animus and Anima consists of two essays of about 50 pages each. The first essay is entitled ”A Post on the Animus Problem”. Here Emma Jung discusses the female individuation process that is directed towards integrating the inner masculinity, the animus. Through a series of cases where she refers to and analyzes the clients' nightly dreams, she describes how the integration phase can be reflected in our dream life. She further explains how the inner split between the biological sex and the inner, natural opposite-sex potential arises as our unconscious is projected onto our surroundings. Including how we humans project our inner masculinity or femininity onto external men or women. And thus, so to speak, we abdicate the responsibility and the opportunity to experience these qualities within ourselves.

”The state in which one is captivated by another and is completely under his influence is called 'transference', which is the same as projection. Projection, however, does not only mean the transfer of an image onto another person. Along with the image, the activities associated with it are also transferred, in the sense that the man onto whom the Animus image is transferred is expected to take over all the functions that have remained undeveloped in the woman in question. This may be the ability to think, the power of action or a sense of responsibility towards the outside world, whereas the woman onto whom the man has projected his Anima is supposed to feel for him or establish relationships for him.

This symbiotic relationship is, in my opinion, the real cause of the forced dependence that exists in such cases. Often a state of completely successful projection does not last very long – especially not if there is no close relationship between the two people. Very soon it happens that the discrepancy between the image and the one who carries it becomes obvious. An archetype, such as the Animus, will never completely coincide with an individual person, and the greater the individuality, the greater the gap. (…)

When this distinction between the image and the person sets in, one discovers, to one's great confusion and disappointment, that the man who seemed to incarnate the Animus image does not correspond to it at all, but constantly behaves differently than one thinks he should. (…) Once one has discovered the discrepancy between man and figure, one is already in the middle of the conflict (the Animus problem), and there is nothing else to do but to carry out a process that consists of distinguishing between the inner image and the man who bears it.”

(EJ, pp. 18-19)

In short, this is precisely a summary of the work that is crucial if love is to be deepened: The effort it takes to see through the veil of infatuation and discover the real person hiding behind it, so that the illusion of infatuation has the opportunity to transform into actual love, which requires that one sees and loves the other as he or she is.

 

Anima as a natural being

The book's second essay, "Anima as a natural being," describes the male journey of development - including the integration of inner femininity.

Here we examine the mythological landscape of the anima figure.

Focusing on developmental processes in the male psyche from the first infant steps to a refined nuance of consciousness that is realized – and internalized – as he unites with his anima and integrates the female aspects into his personality.

”Receptivity is a female tendency that presupposes openness and emptiness, and CG Jung calls this quality the great secret of the female psyche. Furthermore, the female psyche is less reluctant to the irrational than the rationally oriented male consciousness, which tends to reject everything that is not rational and which consequently often cuts itself off from the unconscious. (…)

In the development of the male ego-consciousness, the feminine side is pushed into the background and sinks into a ”natural” state. The same thing happens in the differentiation of the psychological functions. The so-called inferior function is pushed into the background, remains undifferentiated and unconscious and is therefore linked to the equally unconscious Anima.

Redemption lies in the recognition and integration of this unconscious soul element.”

(EJ, p. 63)

Anima and animus are described as gradually manifesting in the individuation process. In the second part of the book, Emma Jung illustrates this relationship by reviewing a variety of cases focusing on what a man's dream life and world of experience would typically look like as the anima figure emerges on the threshold of consciousness.

This review, together with the book's selected legends and myths that put the relevance of the anima and animus figures to psychological development into perspective, points the reader in the direction of how one can identify inner landmarks and establish a navigation system in one's own development process.

 

Integration and individuation

Why this interest in the unconscious? Can't it just remain unconscious, do we need to address the whole thing?

According to the author and the psychoanalytic environment she was part of, working on making the unconscious conscious and integrating it is essential if we want personal development and maturation. And it is probably only to a lesser extent up to the individual whether we will or not:

”The unconscious not only tends to remain in its primordial state and to engulf and annihilate everything conscious, it also exhibits a clear activity in the opposite direction. (…) The urge for greater consciousness apparently emanates from the archetypes, as if it were an instinct striving towards this goal. Where this impulse comes from and what kind of dynamic triggers it is not known. It belongs to the unsolved secrets of the psyche and life.”

(EJ, p. 85)

Here we stand on the threshold between depth psychology and spirituality, which Emma Jung does not go into but simply calls "the unsolved secrets of the psyche and life.".

The material treated in the book seems to express the human urge to awaken to his life and his potentials. The book itself also speaks of the unconscious and describes the aspects we must necessarily recognize and integrate in a process of individuation in order to reach a greater inner wholeness and meaning. The anima and animus figures are thus a designation of these unrecognized aspects that want to approach consciousness and be accepted by it.

We conclude with Emma Jung's own beautiful and optimistic ending – which could just as well have been written today.

”The moment Anima is recognized and integrated, a changed attitude towards the feminine in general occurs. This new assessment of the feminine principle also entails a due reverence for nature. With the prevailing intellectual attitude in this age of science and technology, there has been a use, even exploitation, of nature rather than a reverence for it. Fortunately, there are signs today that point in the direction of the latter. (…)

In our time, when divisive forces are threateningly dividing people, individuals and atoms, it is doubly necessary that those who want unity and cohesion also have a say. For life depends on the harmonious interplay of male and female forces, also in the individual human being.”

(EJ, p. 93)

 


 

It may be difficult to find 'Animus and Anima' in bookstores, but here it is a link to a pdf of the English translation ⋙

 


 

* The concept of archetypes in this context is understood as original or mythological images and symbols of universal and timeless ideas. Examples of archetypes are the hero, the witch, the queen, the king, the princess, the prince, the monster, the warrior, the mother, the father, the child, etc.

Anima and Animus are two such archetypes.

The blog post is narrated by Morten Winkler.


 

Hanneli Ågotsdatter
Master of Architecture, psychotherapist and meditation teacher.
Hanneli established Kontemplation in 2010 and is the platform's daily manager.
She is affiliated Center for Systems Awareness in Boston and leads the contemplative part of the center's educational program.
Together with Martijn van Beek is she responsible for Mind&Life Europe international retreats for young researchers.
She is part of The Children's Life Skills Association.
Hanneli is a permanent teacher at Vækstcenteret and receives practical guidance from Jes Bertelsen.
She lives in an interplay between family life, an outgoing work life, and withdrawal in long-term retreats.

 

 

FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM

Follow on Instagram
Follow on Instagram