
Lately I've had to talk to trees a few times.
I live surrounded by trees on a daily basis. I have done so for most of my life. I have not only looked at them, but I have climbed them, pruned them, planted them, fallen from them, cut them down, kicked them, cursed at them, breathed with them for a large part of my life.
But I've never talked to a tree before.
The first time was in Mols, in the middle of the national park. I was visiting the performing arts company Secret Hotel with a group of students. Within the framework of a very concrete, physical location, the Secret Hotel providing tools for being in the landscape in new ways. Some simple approaches that offer alternatives, not just for sensing, but for being in the world here and now.
The exercise was actually quite simple. After we had walked out into the countryside in silence for a bit, we stood in a loose semicircle. Here we were told that we had to look around and each find a tree or bush that we could connect with. Then we had to go up to it or that one and talk to it for five to ten minutes, in whatever way felt natural: an inner monologue, loud speech, physical exchange, we had to do that ourselves. “You start, now.”
And then you stand there and look around, and there's nothing really calling you, but still the group of themselves is spread out across the landscape, probably within sight, but barely within earshot, at least not if you whisper. It was an open hill with bushes and scattered clumps of trees. I wandered around and ended up at a birch tree that stood somewhat by itself. And then we stood there, middle-aged tree and middle-aged man facing each other. Did I talk to it? In a way. Just walking around it, looking closer and closer, seeing the furrows in the bark and the ants coming up it, opened something up. Do the ants come if you're a tree? The tree filled my mind and my senses, and even though not much was said, there was a kind of strong inner dialogue: What is it like, tree, to be right here, alone on the slope? The view is fantastic, the feeling of space and room, but why alone, when the others huddle together, a little further away? What is it like in winter, in the wind? The answer hung quietly and expectantly in the air between us. As I left, I turned around, looked one last time at my tree, light in body and mind, and bowed gently in farewell.
The next time was a few months later in Northern Italy, specifically in Reggio Emilia, the capital of a region known for cheese, ham, vinegar and a unique early childhood education system that takes its name from the city. Here, a group of dedicated educators, thinkers and aesthetes have developed a unique approach to how adults can support children's creative exploration of their surroundings.
It's about becoming a participant in that project, supporting it, giving it the conditions to grow, and along the way learning something about yourself and about the world.
We were a mixed group from North America, South Africa, Asia, Europe visiting Reggio Emilia at the school's headquarters. Malaguzzi Center. Most were academics, some were practitioners in teaching and communication, and we were all left to the experienced educators.
They challenged us with one of their classic exercises for preschoolers. Equipped with a drawing pad and paints, we were sent out into the garden to find a tree to talk to. We could draw what we experienced, we could also not, but we had to think of a gift for the tree, in recognition of our exchange with it. It felt a little less strange to find a tree to talk to the second time.
In front of the building stood two rows of deciduous trees. A little inside one row I was attracted by one that split into two trunks right at the ground, the left one sloping out into the open, the right one sloping in towards the other row. I walked around the tree, looked up, there were creepers climbing up the trunks. On the left one they had been pruned, so that only the dead network of shoots remained. On the right one they continued luxuriantly upwards. What is it like, tree, to support another growth? Does it parasitize and take the light, does it give something or other, or is it just okay that it uses you to get up too? The details in the bark. Furrows, cracks, and again insects on their way up and down.
I put my ear to the two stems. When I listened to the left one, I heard a beating heart, warmth, love. When I listened to the right one, it was darker, almost black, and I heard a knife. Or maybe hear is not the right word. What does a knife sound like? The experience was synesthetic: I listen, and what I hear is an image, an emotion.
I looked up at the left trunk, the one with the heart. It was growing vigorously and spreading freely into the open space. The right one was also growing well, so much so that it grew into the row next to it and crushed its neighboring tree, which stood with half-withered branches. I listened. Life, energy, heart and knife. Did I hear a bully trampling others around him? But at the same time the heart. I spoke to the tree. You are ok, you are a lot of love, you are the biggest, no need to crush the others, there is enough space. Give me space.
We went inside. I took a lump of clay, the tree, is going to have a medal. It's going to be a star with a one on it: “You are number one.” But my design skills haven't changed since kindergarten, and I can't do what I want. The star turns into a heart with a one on it. And I go out into the garden and hang the heart on the tree and say, "You're the biggest, your heart is big, so you can give some space. Put the knife away."“
The next morning I woke up with the tree in my head and the strong sense of reality that only a dream can give. Maybe I was wrong. Maybe the knife is not a condition but a wish: “prune me so I don’t bother, and remove the creeper at the same time.” That’s the first thing I say to my hosts when we meet a little later in the day. They thank me and want to take it to the gardener.
As at Mols, the exercise, however bizarre it may seem in its projection, was not only fun and entertaining, but also thought-provoking and, in the moment, deeply meaningful. Had I conversed with the tree? Maybe, maybe not, but I took with me a strong experience of perspective, or rather of lived perspectives. Perspectives that were both unfolded out of and into the small concrete piece of reality, like the garden in front of Malaguzzi Center is.

In cognitive research, there has been a growing interest in how we as humans relate to other people in recent years. One of the central ideas is that humans have a special ability to imagine that other people have minds. This 'theory of mind' (known as theory of mind), allows one to think of the other as separate from oneself. What I know is not necessarily what you know; your feeling is not necessarily my feeling; your world is not necessarily my world, but if I think about it, I may be able to figure out what your world looks like.
An important study of this theory is the so-called Sally-Anne test. It is a little play for two dolls, two baskets and a stone, which many young children have been exposed to. The doll Sally hides a stone in a basket and disappears from the scene. While Sally is gone, the naughty Anne takes the stone and moves it from one basket to the other. Then Sally comes back. The question for the child is now: Where will Sally look for the stone? Does she look in the basket she has put it in, or in the one where the stone is actually? If the child has a theory of mind, she will be aware that Sally's knowledge is not the same as the child's, but that Sally will act on her own knowledge, and therefore look in the wrong basket. Without a theory of mind, the theory says, the child will answer that Sally is looking where the stone actually is.
Later, the theory of mind split into two. The 'theory of mind' said that when you separated the other from yourself, you did so by making a distinct model of what the other might know, think, or feel. The simulation theory, on the other hand, proposed a simpler solution. You simply put yourself in the other's place, and then, using yourself as a starting point, you simulate what it would be like if I were the other. The difference may seem subtle, but it has kept psychologists and philosophers busy for many years, and the number of articles written about it has cost the lives of countless trees. The simulation theory was initially apparently supported by the discovery of so-called mirror neurons in the brain. These are cells that seem to be active both when you yourself perform an action and when you see someone else do it. The proponents of the theory believed that they had found a concrete mechanism by which, by simulating yourself, you could imagine the other. This means that one does not need to formulate a distinct image of the other very clearly. On the other hand, simulation theory has a really hard time explaining how one can imagine what it is like to be very different from oneself.
In recent years, most researchers have agreed that it may not be either simulation theory or theory-theory. Both may be at play, simultaneously or separately. Instead, the focus has shifted away from the highly observational approach to the other, which is the expression of theory of mind, to an investigation of how people can do things with each other. When actions intertwine in real time, dance, conversation, play, or collaboration, it happens so quickly that there is hardly time for either simulation or theorizing. When the interaction is successful, it is very concrete evidence that one can both adapt to each other and to a certain extent anticipate what the other will do, and this is also how it looks from the other's point of view. Thus, there is probably someone at home both with oneself and with the other. Rather than the opposition between theory and simulation, this tension between observation and participation seems to be what characterizes our ways of relating to each other, but that is a completely different story...
Was it my 'theory of mind' that played tricks on me in the 'talking-to-trees' exercises? Maybe. My experience can clearly be accused of 'anthropomorphizing' the trees: that is, attributing to them feelings, intentions and ideas as if they were people. In a reality where humans are thought of as separate from all other living things, this is a serious mistake, bordering on a conceptual mortal sin. It is like when people talk to their dogs and cats as if they had a mind with feelings, intentions and thoughts.
By nature, I can neither simulate nor imagine what it would be like to be a completely different life form. One that simply stands there, with its roots deeply rooted in the ground and its branches reaching towards the light, stretched between nourishment and energy.
But the experience was there anyway, at the same time both physical, sensory, emotional, spiritual and deeply satisfying. A realization of, or perhaps rather an acknowledgement that there can be a perspective that is the tree's, and that one can perhaps exchange with it.
In this way, the exercises affect my way of being in the world, and thus also the world itself.
One of the other participants in Reggio Emilia made a pair of glasses for her tree. She had studied the tree’s bark structure closely and had seen in it some outlines that looked like eyes looking at her. The glasses were, she explained, an acknowledgement of the tree’s gaze at her: “I have seen that you have seen me!”
She was an American, raised on a Midwestern farm with a grandmother who talked to her plants. “You just have to walk among them and listen to them,” her grandmother had said, “and they will tell you what they need.” My colleague had never quite understood what that meant, but the glasses were a kind of illustration of her very concrete experience that there could also be a gaze that was the tree’s.

Gaze, perspective; the metaphor is at once concrete and abstract. At least since the Renaissance, central perspective has been one of the most important ways in which we have represented the gaze. In a painting, this is shown by the fact that all the lines in the image converge towards a vanishing point in the distance, and at the same time the lines extend imaginary outwards towards the viewers, towards the place from which the vanishing point can be seen. There is much to suggest that this ideal observation point for the painters was a very concrete place. A lens that made it possible to project the lines in the landscape onto a canvas behind the lens. If this is correct, central perspective also becomes a very concrete manifestation of the notion of a privileged perspective from which the world is seen. The perspective from which the picture is drawn.
Also due to our all-encompassing interaction with images produced by cameras and lenses, central perspective today often seems so 'natural' and realistic that we do not experience it as a perspective at all. That is simply how reality is. But the notion of a single central perspective has recently been exposed to an interesting challenge that is both high-tech and low-tech at the same time. The English artist David Hockney is investigating, among other things, how he can use an iPad to explore our perception of reality. In the image Card Players #3 from 2014 he has drawn three men playing cards at a table while a fourth looks on. The picture looks very 'real', but if you look at the lines in it, there is something wrong with the central perspective. The green table they are playing at is narrowest closest to the viewer, and it spreads out to the back, but still appears rectangular, the background is larger than the foreground, the periphery larger than the center, what is happening? Hockney says that the picture is drawn on the basis of a myriad of photographs, all taken very close up. The heads, the jackets, the shoes are all photographed separately, and afterwards it is all combined into a painted picture with many vanishing points, many perspectives, folded into the same canvas. The effect is, says Hockney, a bit like 3D, but without the glasses. Digital technology therefore allows us to combine a multitude of perspectives in one image, and thus, Hockney suggests, we can free ourselves from the central perspective we have lived with since the Renaissance, in our time strongly supported by photography.i
In a way, Hockney's picture is a way of showing reality, in a perspective that is simultaneously many, many different perspectives.
There is neither mind nor theories of mind in these perspectives, per se, but still a deep recognition of the world as fundamentally perspectival, even when viewed from one place. This is, I think, a very important breakthrough, besides being terribly good art…
And that brings me, perhaps, back to the experiences of talking to the trees. Perhaps the exercise provides a very concrete experience that the world is full of possible perspectives, even the perspective of the tree. Each of these perspectives can, at least potentially, be inhabited by someone who does not have to be like oneself. Perhaps this is the gift that the 'theory of mind' gives us: an ability to both concretely and imaginaryly connect to, and thus live in, a world of possible perspectives, each inhabited by a possible mind. The recognition of this radical perspectivism requires, I think, an unlearning of some of the practices that have been with us for a very long time. One can presumably approach it both via the digital and via the analog. It seems that sometimes by connecting closely to that which is very different, one can look deeply into oneself; and other times by looking deeply into oneself, one can connect to the other, the other, as both oneself and as radically different. To absorb such experiences of perspectives and of minds, both in the plural, is perhaps one of the great challenges of our time.
iSee discussion at (http://www.annelyjudafineart.co.uk/exhibitions/painting-and-photography-david-hockney#img10). I am indebted to British neuroscientist Colin Blakemore for drawing my attention to Hockney's work and for offering an interpretation of it.
Talking to trees; an exercise in perspective first published as a contribution to the article series Spirit in Everyday Life.
Andreas Roepstorff
is a professor of brain and cognition research and head of Interacting Minds Centre at Aarhus University, an institute he himself created and built up.
The Carlsberg Foundation has awarded him the title of 'researcher of the year'. He has managed to simultaneously elevate his institute and its research in consciousness to the international forefront while maintaining his inner playboy and a low-key kindness and respect that make him an unusual and beloved leader.