MEDIATION IN INTERNATIONAL CONFLICT

Daniel Sebastian

My work with conflicts abroad began in collaboration with members of the then newly founded Center for Conflict Resolution. We held courses in Montenegro during (and after) the war in the Balkans, and I slowly expanded my activities to other conflict areas, including South Africa.

Here, two forms of conflict management were illustrated; the traditional and the reflexive (see description in '‘Conflict understanding, cohesion and mutual responsibility'’). Also in connection with post-war and civil war settlements, and even with regard to gross human rights violations, I have seen forms of reaction that can be said to be so different that they have parallels in the two paradigms,[xii] which will be illustrated below.

The typical reaction in the aftermath of wars, civil wars and crimes is that the victims want justice or revenge in the form of punishment, and that the perpetrators want to forget, to move on – possibly in the form of granting amnesty. Both reactions are probably generally human.

Classic settlements after wars and civil wars are tribunals, for example in Yugoslavia and the Rwandan tribunals, and truth commissions in, for example, El Salvador.

The differences between these are that while one model, the tribunal, primarily appears to serve the interests of society (and the world community), and has as its goal punishment and revenge and a possible preventive effect, the truth commission, as it is known from, for example, El Salvador, was apparently originally established with the interests of the victims in mind, namely in the form of the desire for recognition of and documentation of what was committed. During the process, however, the consideration often changes to primarily serving the perpetrators' desire for oblivion, resulting in a general amnesty.

The similarities between the two forms of response are the desire for justice and the respect for a settlement with the past. In addition, there is the important but often overlooked similarity that both modes of response neglect consideration for the other party and thus deprive the relationship, the cohesion, of meaning. Regardless of which of the two modes of response is used, it overlooks the fact that both victims and perpetrators have not only lived through a war together, but also – at least at some point – must live side by side in a common future.

Against this background, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC = Truth and Reconciliation Commission) in South Africa as unique because it was an attempt to consider the needs of both victims and perpetrators. The construction of the TRC came about after an open democratic debate, and it was based on a conviction that the parties had had a common past and now had to build a common future, and that they would destroy each other if this conviction was not successfully put into practice. The parties' mutual connectedness was thus given weight. The conditions were, among other things, that perpetrators could receive individual amnesty under the crucial condition that each individual had acknowledged and publicly spoken about the human rights violations they had committed (described with the slogans ’'amnesty, no amnesia'’), and that the victims (or their families) could publicly talk about the abuse they suffered and could receive compensation.

The TRC worked with three different conceptions of truth: a factual (legal) truth that could be proven, and a social or 'dialogical' truth that emerged through an interactive process, which could be culturally determined and historically grounded, and therefore not necessarily factually correct. Furthermore, the TRC recognized a healing and personal truth that could emerge from the narratives told by victims (or their families), and which could contribute to the collective truths that were recognized as having to coexist.[xiii] It is precisely the recognition of the often relative truth in the narratives of the parties that is a central part of understanding conflict.

It can therefore be argued with some justification that these different modes of reaction after wars and civil wars can be classified within the two previously described paradigms.

It is beyond the scope of this article to provide a further description of the work and developments within the TRC. However, it should be mentioned that South Africa – despite the TRC's undeniable shortcomings, for example the failure to provide compensation to victims and the failure to observe due process – today stands as a shining example of a showdown after gross human rights violations: First, after the public and lengthy process, it is no longer possible to deny that the many violations have taken place, and second, the public recognition of the relationship, the solidarity between victims and perpetrators, has created an insight into the basis for reconciliation that – despite all the challenges – has never been present before.

Apparently, a new legal society can neither be built on a thirst for revenge nor on impunity. The quality of the confrontation with the crimes of the former regime will be decisive for the future sense of justice and the entire future society's experience of coherence. Should the past be avenged or repressed, or should it be remembered and acknowledged? The answers to these questions seem crucial both for the design of society's institutions and for the parties' possible common future in a rebuilt country.

 

Footnotes:

[xii] There has been a considerable amount of experience with the use of dialogue in international conflicts as well. Generative dialogue is seen in this context as existing when the parties perceive a common shift in their understanding and/or their relationship with others and the issue or problem that the dialogue has encompassed, see e.g. C. Otto Scharmer, Theory U, 2007. See also The Folke Bernadotte Academy, www.folkebernadotteacademy.se, which in their courses has attempted to convey precisely this understanding of dialogue to people involved in international conflicts.

[xiii] Albie Sachs, The Strange Alchemy of Life and Law, Oxford, 2009,

 

Illustration: Daniel Sebastian Hoeg


Mediating in international conflicts has been edited and arranged for Kontemplation's blog. The text was first published as part of Vibeke Vindeløv's contribution to the article series Spirit in Everyday Life.


 

Vibeke Vindeløv
is a lawyer, psychotherapist and professor of conflict mediation at the Faculty of Law, University of Copenhagen. She is the author of several articles and books on law, mediation and reconciliation. She has extensive experience in teaching and practical work with conflict resolution and mediation in a variety of conflict types. She is interested in the connection between value and action and the large and small conflict. Geographical focal points for her international work have been Southeastern Europe (Balkans) and South Africa.

FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM

Follow on Instagram
Follow on Instagram