Conflict understanding, cohesion and mutual responsibility
of | Internal practice and working life | June 20, 2020
I became a lawyer by a roundabout route. As a practicing lawyer, I was quickly confronted with the fact that the law's focus on the rights of the individual was not the path to greater joy and satisfaction for most parties. It had to be done better. That's why I began studying psychology, trained as a therapist and, under expert guidance, began to meditate. My task (as a lawyer and spiritual seeker) was then to try to take the most important things from both forms and combine them: On this basis, 'mediation with a reflexive approach' was born. A practice where the value-based basis is crucial, combined with a structure and momentum inspired by legal conflict management.
In my work, it became increasingly clear that ways of handling conflicts roughly follow two different paradigms, which represent different values and understandings – including different understandings of the importance of cohesion and mutual responsibility.
One paradigm is called the »traditional« one. It is used, for example, in the courts, but also underlies many of the attitudes towards conflicts in politics and in everyday conflicts that we encounter in the public, both in the Western world and elsewhere.
The second paradigm – of which reflexive mediation is an example – is called »the new« because the context in which it is described is of recent date and does not correspond to what is found behind mediation in history or in so-called indigenous cultures. In these contexts, the community will often be (or is) given importance at the expense of the wishes and needs of the individual, that is, mediation here does not happen, or happened, in harmony with, but after disregarding and completely subordinating the individual.[vii]
Even if we wanted to, it is probably impossible at this point to imagine that we could do without, for example, courts. We must recognize that there is sometimes a need for an authority as a 'backstop' to prevent conflicts from developing too destructively. What one could wish for, however, is a greater awareness of the attitudes and views of humanity on which the two paradigms are each based, and thus which method one (wants to) practice. Perhaps one can even see the two forms as yin and yang, respectively, where neither can be dispensed with, and together they form a whole.
For the sake of clarity, the paradigms below are described in schematic form.
| Traditional paradigm | New paradigm |
|---|---|
| Conflicts are disruptive | Conflicts are a condition of life |
| The parties are counterparties and do not recognize a relationship between them. | The parties are individuals who see themselves as mutually connected in a common conflict. |
| There is an ”objective” truth | No party has a patent on the whole truth. |
| Focus on results/agreement | Focus on dialogical process and possible outcome/agreement |
| Winner/loser | Consideration for both parties |
| An outsider can decide the conflict | The parties must participate in and take full responsibility for the resolution of their conflict. |
| Sanction option is necessary | Sanctions are of minor importance |
Paradigm – the traditional and the new
The human perspective behind the traditional paradigm is based on a fundamental belief that an authority is necessary to find good solutions on behalf of the parties, as they do not have the necessary resources to find them themselves.
Behind the new paradigm lies a humility towards the situation, a reluctance to pry into the lives of others, and a trust that the parties – possibly by failing – will go through a process whereby they find solutions that are useful in their lives.
The new paradigm recognizes the relative nature of the concept of truth and interconnectedness, and this naturally leads to reciprocity and dynamic reflection by the parties, including reflection on how one party's actions affect the other - a reflection that is not necessary in the traditional paradigm. The understanding of coherence is therefore represented in the new paradigm, and often absent in the traditional paradigm.
In the traditional paradigm, one follows rules and dogmas and looks for the correct solution within a hierarchical structure. In the new paradigm, the good result is that which the parties agree on and which satisfies both of them (or all parties, if there are more than two) to the greatest extent possible.
The dialogical and investigative process therefore becomes necessary. This process can be described as an investigative, unpredictable and risky conversation, where the best solution is not given in advance. The only thing that is given in advance is that no one can produce a satisfactory solution or understanding alone. Dialogue can be clarified in three words: share, dare spirit care, share, dare and take care: You must share your experiences, skills and perspectives (phare), one must run the risk of being wrong or becoming wiser by presenting one's views and basic assumptions for joint examination (dare), and we must take care of each other and build a proper community that provides space for both dialogue and a common future (care). [ix] Through dialogue, we can explore the deeper meaning contained in a point of view or claim, and we can reveal differences in the dialogue, which then make it possible to find common ground.
Solutions achieved on this basis are often more satisfactory and therefore more sustainable than solutions achieved on the basis of an authoritarian decision.
With support from Buber, we can say that the starting point is that we as humans are placed towards something being with which we can enter into an interactive relationship. This interaction can be either an I-it attitude or an I-thou attitude. The I-it attitude is practiced within the traditional paradigm, where, according to Buber, one makes the other an object, and where a fundamental one-sidedness (gradually or from the start) will empty the relationship of reality, for ”I-it can never be said with one’s whole being”. Thus, the professional – the judge, the expert – will always maintain a distance from the object of expertise, the parties.
Since dialogue is necessary in the new paradigm, it must be a dialogue in Buber's sense, a dialogue that presupposes an I-Thou relationship. The new paradigm recognizes that reciprocity is present, and that the individual person comes into being precisely in this interaction, and that "I-Thou can only be said with one's whole being." [x] No one is or can be an expert in the life of another, and our responsibility therefore becomes boats for our own lives and for the other's.
It goes without saying that it may happen that you as a mediator do not live up to the values of the new paradigm. In that case, it is important to recognize that it is not the values that are wrong, but that you have encountered challenges that you were unable to handle for various reasons. Help may then be necessary.
An example from my own practice, where I just managed to handle the challenges, might illustrate this:
Shortly after the end of the war in the Balkans, I was asked to hold a workshop in Sarajevo for approximately 20 participants. The Danish side had donated money for a project that would only be actualized if the employees represented all three ethnic groups, Bosnians, Serbs and Croats. Since the theme of the course was conflicts, I was aware that a lot of pain and hatred could come out of the participants during the course. Unless I wanted to keep the process on the surface, which I did not want to, it would be a demanding task. My mental preparation therefore took up a lot. I decided to work consciously with my contact with the feelings of the heart. In addition to my usual meditation, I therefore went up to the hotel room during every break during the course to rediscover my inner center and strengthen the contact with the heart and compassion. I insisted on maintaining an I-you relationship. It was heartbreaking and frightening to be with the participants in their process, and I am convinced that had I not been helped by my exercises, the I-it attitude would have taken over. The exercises helped me to stay 'standing' when the stories and confrontations became violent.
I also both hope and dare to believe that they helped the participants.
In my practical work as a mediator, I have countless examples of how I quickly – and often too quickly – formed an idea of how a given conflict should be resolved. The trap was right there when I acted in contexts that were familiar to me. Gradually, experience has taught me to maintain openness, after which the parties themselves can find solutions that are so much better than those I could have suggested.
I have had the same experience in international contexts.
For these experiences I have found a beautiful expression in the 12th-century Persian jurist, theologian and mystic Abu Hamid al-Ghazzal in the first part of his On the revival of the religious sciences: Here he says about knowledge:
”He who wants to debate should seek the truth in the same spirit as he who is looking for a thing he has lost: he does not care whether the thing is found by himself or by a helper. He considers his interlocutor a friend, and not an adversary. And he thanks his partner every time the latter points out an error and shows him the truth. Therefore, if he himself follows one path after what he has lost, and his partner advises him to take another path, he will not criticize him, but instead thank him, honor him, and rejoice with him.”[xi]
Footnotes:
[vii] Vibeke Vindeløv, Japan as a partner and opponent in civil law conflicts, TfR 1990, pp. 889-906 and the same, Ecology of Mind as a Decisive Basis in Conflict Resolution – A Preliminary Comparison between Japan and Denmark, Copenhagen 1994, TfR 1994, pp. 66-77.
[viii] Vibeke Vindeløv, Conflict, Dispute and Mediation, Copenhagen 1997, chapter 16.
[ix] Marianne Kristiansen and Jørgen Bloch-Poulsen, Dialogue and dialogical competences – a new form of power? In Helle Alrø and Marianne Kristensen (eds.): Dialogue and power in organizations, Aalborg University Press 2004, pp. 11-34.
[x] Martin Buber, I and You, 3rd ed., 4th edition, Hans Reitzel Forlag, 2014
[xi] Thanks to Jakob Skovgaard Pedersen for bringing this quote to my attention.
“Conflict Understanding – Traditional and New” has been edited and organized for Kontemplation’s blog. The text was first published as part of Vibeke Vindeløv’s contribution to the article series Spirit in Everyday Life.
Vibeke Vindeløv
is a lawyer, psychotherapist and professor of conflict mediation at the Faculty of Law, University of Copenhagen. She is the author of several articles and books on law, mediation and reconciliation. She has extensive experience in teaching and practical work with conflict resolution and mediation in a variety of conflict types. She is interested in the connection between value and action and the large and small conflict. Geographical focal points for her international work have been Southeastern Europe (Balkans) and South Africa.

